CONSTANT CRITIC

Timely Criticism and Reviews of Print and Digital Poetry


Ray McDaniel Reviews Liam Agrani’s Volume One (Selected Anonymous Marginalia)

But what his “editorial” choices reveal is that marginalia itself is a kind of dress rehearsal for authorship. Whoever writes in the margin does so with at least as many motivations as whoever writes…

Read More

Elizabeth-Jane Burnett Reviews Nisha Ramayya’s Correspondences

“Tantra is marked by its difficulty,” Nisha Ramayya states in the opening “Notes on Tantra” section of Correspondences, a twenty-six page pamphlet of poetry, micro-essays, notes, and images.

Read More

Ray McDaniel Reviews Trouble in Mind by Lucie Brock-Broido

I offer this distinction between talent well-spent and talent on a spending spree of its own to clarify my mightily mixed feelings about Lucie Brock-Broido’s Trouble in Mind, which poses a number of…

Read More

James Butler-Gruett Reviews Margaret Ross’s Saturday

What the poems in Margaret Ross’s new collection, Saturday, do best is churn.

Read More

Jordan Davis Reviews Lorenzo Thomas’s “Chances Are Few”

Yes, this poet is wide awake to injustice, folly, and ordinary sadness.

Read More

Joyelle McSweeney Reviews Stephen Ratcliffe’s SOUND/(system)

This sense of being at the center of a thought-scape expanding in all directions—and dimensions—is precisely the experience of reading a single page of SOUND/(system).

Read More

John Spiegel Reviews Yerra Sugarman’s Aunt Bird

This is not an elegy to the life of Feiga, it is an elegy for the many possible lives Feiga could have lived. It is an exploration of the unknown, sorrow for what could have been, if not for what…

Read More

Joyelle McSweeney Reviews Donald Revell’s My Mojave

Injured hymns came issuing from the vicinity of Donald Revell’s previous volume, the elegiac Arcady; his new book, My Mojave, stands the respective ground of its title.

Read More

Ray McDaniel Reviews Monica Youn’s Barter

As a metaphor, of course, clarity fails. This idea that the language of which poetry is made exists optimally as a transparent sheet, a substance through which Something Other can best be…

Read More

Jordan Davis Reviews Mary Ruefle’s Apparition Hill

Mary Ruefle’s poetry has always preferred to be read at twilight, when what appears at first to be a tissue of wryly-observed but loosely related details can become in an instant as solid as a…

Read More

Ray McDaniel Reviews Olena Kalytiak Davis’s shattered sonnets love cards and other off and back handed importunities

Reading shattered sonnets et al is like reading an anthology of love poems condensed, crushed, laced with a mild hallucinogen, and distilled—via loop and tube and silly straw—into a mead and…

Read More

Illuminations ‘in Wake of the Virus’: Complimentary Commentaries

The unsuspecting reader is launched at once into the maelstrom of the codex containing a variety of poems in addition to the titular two which are presented in the reverse order suggested in the…

Read More

Between Omens, Amens, Demands, Amends: Conversation with Adeena Karasick on Ærotomania: The Book of Lumenations

AK: oh i adore how you read this through a musician’s ears / not only taste its rhythms grammar, lexicon but “play” it through its slippery riffs though improvisatory modes of meaning –

Read More

A Stream of Memory: An Interview with Paisley Rekdal on West: A Translation

What I don’t want is for West to become a museum, nor do I want it to be a history because it can’t function as a history. Instead, I think it is an attempt at collective memory.

Read More

Ray McDaniel Reviews Kate Greenstreet’s Young Tambling

In lieu of blurbs, the back cover of Young Tambling simply reads "Based on a true story." Thanks to the quality of the design, this humble claim is both comic, and sort of sublime.

Read More

On Anthony Opal’s Chapbook Series of Translations from the Japanese

There’s a guy in Hillside, Illinois who gets it. He’s been printing these chaste, understated chapbooks of various haiku MVPs: Bashō, Buson, Issa, others: the exact guys you find in books like The…

Read More

Karla Kelsey Reviews The Invention of Glass

“Transparency” and “opacity” also, of course, describe different qualities of language, a resonance particularly significant for this book, whose original French title, L’Invention du verre, yields a…

Read More

Ray McDaniel Reviews Brenda Coultas’ A Handmade Museum

I had a hell of a good time with A Handmade Museum, in which Brenda Coultas commits the fairly uncommon trick of going to both country and town.

Read More

Jordan Davis Reviews Joseph Donahue’s Incidental Eclipse

"I was in Dallas when Kennedy was shot," Joseph Donahue wrote, in a poem called “Seven” in his memorable debut, Before Creation, thus giving a characteristically radiant and weird answer to the…

Read More

Joyelle McSweeney Reviews Fanny Howe’s Gone

Fanny Howe’s Gone reads like a soul’s travelogue in installments, a turning over of themes, positions, and bodies as the author seeks, as Simone Weil did, to maintain a conversion through……

Read More

Ray McDaniel Reviews Cal Bedient’s The Violence of the Morning

I respond to these lines with a No despite the fact that the poem puts no question to me at all. This last point, actually, is fully emblematic of The Violence of the Morning entire: this book gives…

Read More

Ray McDaniel Reviews Katie Ford’s Deposition

It’s all here, compressed into these several poems: Ford’s capacity for a breathlessness that achieves articulation by ache, as well as her periodic reliance on academic lacunae that undermine the…

Read More

Jordan Davis Reviews Serge Fauchereau’s Complete Fiction

And really, there’s no reason to doubt that there could be a secret someone writing such sentences as, “Sure, words are just words, sounds uttered in the void, little ants frozen against the…

Read More

Pharma Culture and the Poetic Mind: Michael Workman Reviews Anne Yoder’s The Enhancers

There are more drugs than there are ailments to treat. Yoder plays some language games with the endless variety of names: AnxietyEZ, Delixir, Sunkiss – you get the picture. They rearrange brain…

Read More

Ray McDaniel Reviews Bryan Dietrich’s Krypton Nights

What Dietrich has correctly intuited is that it is the adoption of the cast-off, the negligible, that generates resource—these are lights by which the once-unimagined can be illuminated as the…

Read More

John Spiegel Reviews Winter, Glossolalia by John James

Considering the chapbook’s psalm-like, hymnal musicality, the poem is more a kind of sheet music to be reinterpreted by the reader, the way a musician would determine how to play the notes on the…

Read More

Christine Hume Reviews Sarah Manguso’s The Captain Lands in Paradise

Manguso’s use of the essay—both its argument-driven/fact-rich, and its meditative/associative, heritages—serves her trials of truth vs. falsehood and real vs. symbolic meanings. In this way she…

Read More

Where Buddha Finds You: Brendan White Reviews Joel Craig’s Humanoid

Good poems can feel like people. Richard Rorty, months before his death, wrote that he regretted not reading more poems in the same way he regretted not making more close friends. Joel Craig realizes…

Read More

Jordan Davis Reviews Karen Volkman’s Spar

In this prose poem, inversion is the point, a reasonable defense against the social unknowns of dealing with other animate beings—why not invent a world out of the strong obvious sensory perceptions…

Read More

Poem Without Beginning or End: on the Ramayana and Vivek Narayanan’s After

I think you should read Vivek Narayanan’s After, which is an erudite, funny, chaotic, absorbing book of poems that talks with, alongside, and back to the Ramayana of Valmiki. But you might not be…

Read More

On May’s Lucan

(1) Homer, (2) Virgil, (3) Horace, (4) Ovid, (5) Lucan, (6) Dante—the list is hot.  And I gotta say Lucan’s tenure on that roster was pretty secure, in 1300 or whatever. There were always people who…

Read More

Christine Hume Reviews Lance Phillips’ Corpus Socius

Indeed, “The tongue’s little more a sun” here; you don’t just read this work, you feel it as a foreign tongue in your mouth.

Read More

Jordan Davis Reviews Loren Goodman’s Famous Americans

I would say there are two qualities that Goodman looks for before he decides that a particular language act qualifies as Goodman-worthy: 1) it must include (and if possible splice together) two…

Read More

Ray McDaniel Reviews Ai’s Dread

What Dread demonstrates at moments that rise above those detailed here is that Ai is simply a more vivid and uncanny mimic of evil than she is of those whose lives have been tainted or terminated by…

Read More

Devin King Reviews Douglas Crase’s On Autumn Lake: The Collected Essays

“It was convenient for John Ashbery,” begins the first and titular essay of Douglas Crase’s On Autumn Lake: The Collected Essays, “and dumb luck for me, that I was living in Rochester and could pick…

Read More

Christine Hume Reviews John D’Agata’s The Next American Essay

Though D’Agata does not claim to have coined the term “lyric essay,” nor invented the form, his organizing structure makes it seem as if it sprung into existence as a result of his conception.

Read More

Niina Pollari Reviews Rachel Mannheimer’s Earth Room

When I read about art, I want to read about its movingness to an individual human being, and the ways that the individual has continued to digest it over time. To me, this experience-based art…

Read More

Jordan Davis Reviews Lee Ann Brown’s The Sleep That Changed Everything

Among younger poets, her absolute refusal to accept limits on what is permissible has given her something like political power.

Read More

Halim Madi Interviews Transhuman Poet & Technelegy Author Sasha Stiles 

Maybe a glitch is an emotion. Maybe we’re discovering new cybernetic emotions. I mean, there is always some underlying logic to the machine’s choice, even if it’s not discernible right away.

Read More

Christine Hume Reviews Jenny Boully’s The Body

The Body'‘s title names what’s missing—the textual body as well as the lover’s body. Its echo chamber of fragments tells the afterthoughts of a love affair. If the body is a surface for decipherment…

Read More

Quantum Language Mechanics & Rae Armantrout’s Finalists

How then to engage with a world of no innate properties in a language with no innate meanings? Collision, fusion, and full-blown prepositional contingency distinguish the only kind of poetry I want…

Read More

Ray McDaniel Reviews Timothy Donnelly’s Twenty-seven Props for a Production of Eine Lebenszeit

What wanderlust has wrecked your skirts?
 / They’ve ceased to swish that certain way, // that distingué, the way they did days halcyon,
 / what goings-on have been going on, keep...

Read More

thehumanprojectofgrasping: Lindsey Pannor on Cody-Rose Clevidence’s Dearth & God’s Green Mirth

At the initial moment of reading, the words DEARTH and DEAREARTH float with widened kerning and vertical overlap, titling the opening passage by shadowing one another. In the pages to follow,…

Read More

To Be Now: John Spiegel Reviews Susan Comninos’ Out of Nowhere

Susan Comninos’ debut collection Out of Nowhere is an homage to legacy, where we come from, what it means to follow in the steps of, and how that affects our perception of the present.

Read More

Customized Absence: Aiden Farrell Reviews Tracy Fuad’s about:blank

Fuad’s multi-layered and intersectional project in about:blank embodies the consequences of a global culture in which manipulations and interpretations of experience are taken to be the experience…

Read More

One Who Sits Beside: Sylvia Matas Reviews dg nanouk okpik’s Corpse Whale

okpik’s poems are set in a world where a shaman’s ceremony exists alongside cyberspace; where satellites as well as ancestral spirits circle the earth...

Read More

John Spiegel Reviews The Bold News of Birdcalls by Edward Morin

Humility is necessary when viewing the self, yes, but how does our humility affect our view of the world around us? To Morin, these questions are not so different from one another.

Read More

Hardness as Genesis: Niina Pollari Reviews Outgoing Vessel by Ursula Andkjær Olsen

maybe it’s covered with some kind of unknowable plant, here on this earth long after humans are gone, having taken our small human griefs with us...

Read More

Those Who Live in the Between Spaces: everything saved will be last

everything saved will be last exists in the between spaces while focusing on those who live in the between spaces, and places us squarely between these markers right alongside it.

Read More

The Idea of Perfection: The Poetry and Prose of Paul Valéry

But the symbol in Valéry isn’t naïve—he presents the life of the mind as a series of intersected symbols that never resolve.

Read More

Jordan Davis Reviews Fanny Howe’s Gone and Economics

The best work in each of her new books is literally astonishing—action, thought, and emotion come out of nowhere and vanish just as quickly.

Read More

The Fact of Necessary Drift: The Selected Letters of Robert Creeley

I wish more serious poets strived for this poem’s looseness.

Read More

Jordan Davis Reviews Susan M. Schultz’s Memory Cards & Adoption Papers

“It’s just a picture, Bryant says, not a baby. But it is the form of our baby, his precise measurement on photographic paper, his after-birth mark. I keep my eyes on the web."

Read More

Ray McDaniel Reviews Gabriel Gudding’s A Defense of Poetry

This is the poetry of scatological exhaustion; it is scatological-categorical. It is going too far, perhaps, to accuse Mr. Gudding of playing in his own shit; he is more concerned with the airier…

Read More

A Practice of Immersion: Gloria Frym on Reading

“This habit of reading,” Frym observes, “is a form of protectionism, a kind of amulet to counter the assault that threatens to drown us...

Read More

Having Been Born: Karla Kelsey Reviews Killing Plato and The Semblable by Chantal Maillard

Until we reckon with both of these realities we remain wrapped-up in a false idea of ourselves. Until we reckon we consign ourselves to narrow circles of concern, protecting and tending only those…

Read More

On David Hinton’s Translations from Chinese: Anthony Madrid Reviews The Selected Poems of Tu Fu: Expanded and Newly Translated

Imagine someone who considered the United States an exotic place of wonders and sages, and so decided to translate place names in a spirit of amped-up magic and mystery. Chicago might be translated…

Read More

Cries of Perfunctory Things: Brendan White Reviews William Fuller’s Daybreak

This is Fuller’s aquarium. To get fully acclimated you probably need to spend ten to twenty minutes in a submerged Ziploc bag.

Read More

The Course: Acoustic Trampoline Makes Possibility Spreading

Their radical endeavors for revolutionary rules and sense-making are indispensable and crucial to the poetry world. To a large extent, they break the frozen sound of the alphabet and offer new…

Read More

Between Now and “the Apocalypse”: Alexandra McIntosh Reviews The Shore by Chris Nealon

In a deeply intersectional quest for liberation, Nealon, a white gay man, reveals his timidities and acknowledges the potential harm in considering his own oppression, confessing, “I don’t want to…

Read More

Totem by Gregory Pardlo

...a masterpiece of subjectivity: all qualia and stunning epithets, big feelings shaded with doubts, regrets, hesitations, and guilt.

Read More

Nest by Mei-mei Berssenbrugge

By exposing the myth of inside/outside, Berssenbrugge’s latest work undermines the basis for alienation.

Read More

book cover with man standing in the middle of soldiers guarding him

The Soldiers of Year II by Medbh McGuckian

"He lies in his English envelope / like the Greek word for Greekness, / defender of Throne and Altar"

Read More

married poet couple standing in snow with leafless trees in background, wife holding their baby wrapped in white blanket

Bernadette Mayer Time Machine: Anthony Madrid Reviews Memory and Piece of Cake

 “Just get the stuff down, whole. Don’t worry ’bout what it means.”  I found myself helplessly admiring their integrity.

Read More

Equivalence by Shin Yu Pai

Some of Pai’s poems are themselves works of visual or conceptual art—instructions for art handlers, poems with concrete elements, and, most delightfully, a series of scripts for DIY art...

Read More

Otherhood by Reginald Shepherd

"words break me, break / from me, branchlets / glinting gray in moon / -light, slivered green by day."

Read More

In Search of Another History: Devin King Reviews City of Beginnings: Poetic Modernism in Beirut

Beirut, looked at from within, was a world escaping from the history that had raised it or given birth to it, a world setting out in the direction of another history, not the one written for it, but…

Read More

Born to Slow Horses by Kamau Brathwaite

Sometimes you should look into the jaws of hell and then look closer. Put your head right between the teeth. You might find rubies in there.

Read More

Manic Clarity: Arthur Russell Reviews The Preembroidered Moment by Jim Klein

It is not poetry about M/D, not a memoir or a victim’s tale, not a survival guide or an analysis; it is a book of poems about humiliation and what comes after humiliation, which is not redemption but…

Read More

Sleeping with the Dictionary by Harryette Mullen

Voice in this work is a figure of hybridity, born from a mongrel American culture to perform transmission between social/cultural/political divides.

Read More

the new black by Evie Shockley

the new black doesn’t need the likes of me to explain or sell it: it shouts, with glee and a kind of genius, its own achievement. But I do want to make a final case in defense of its unapologetic…

Read More

We Still Love, Past Reason: Alexandra McIntosh Reviews Kathleen Graber’s The River Twice

Graber invites us to do what Heraclitus says we cannot—to return to the river of our past.

Read More

There Will Be Light: The Immersive Sky Writing of Aaron Shurin’s The Blue Absolute

In these fluid erotics, the signifiers slide along and blissfully exchange places.  It will be the window that "throbs" and the city that "shivers" while we, dear readers, let go of the guardrails.

Read More

Reclaiming the Complicated: Niina Pollari Reviews Prageeta Sharma’s Grief Sequence

I wish more books would let the many ways in which the grief lingers be the point. This book doesn’t force lessons on its reader, and I’m glad for it.

Read More

I Want It Dripping / John Spiegel Reviews Katy Bohinc’s Scorpio

I found myself laughing as I read these poems, not because the content is inherently humorous, but because I was so amused at what reading them did to me.

Read More

Local Effects: Devin King Reviews Brian Teare’s Doomstead Days

But it’s imagination that got us into this problem, and it’s imagination that’ll get us out.

Read More

Emily Jungmin Yoon’s A Cruelty Special to Our Species: Containing Anxious Ambiguity, with Peaches

It is impossible to simply list the crimes against these women, and that’s where poetry steps in. In the first poem of Cruelty, one of a few prose poems titled “An Ordinary Misfortune,” a friend asks…

Read More

Internet Is For Real Image

the Internet is for real; Everything I forgot I’ll remember…

Because he grew up as an “Other”—with the interstices of two disparate cultures—Campanioni is aware of marginality disrupting pretensions of normalcy, sameness, or assimilation. He is not, in a…

Read More

Two Reviews of Brenda Shaughnessy’s The Octopus Museum

On the one hand, we have poetry as documentation. Sure, poetry, like artifacts in a museum, can provide documentation — but so can op-eds, articles, books of prose, photographs. On the other hand, we…

Read More

A Story of I, Self-Conscious Me: The Year of Blue Water

Is it a story exploring the self, or is it an ironic, self-conscious construction of “I” gesturing towards his uncertainty about the book’s form? The book is so involved with self, isn’t it enough to…

Read More

Druthers by Jennifer Moxley

“I would rather the poem’s score / My ear imprison, then enumerate / The wrongs of late capitalism,” in defiance of the prevailing stream of poetic engagement...

Read More

A Personal Volcano Cracks in the Holocene: A Disaster Series

Having peered into the heart of the volcano and seen the "fiery crack in the world," the poet emerges like a modern Cassandra, an eco-seer, "looking down the barrel of a gun," to hurl her prophecy.

Read More

I Can’t Talk About the Trees Without the Blood || dark // thing

...the systemic racism that underlies language and how we use it—even in experimental art forms like poetry—could be disrupted by new ways we use language.

Read More

Paige Ackerson-Kiely Dolefully, A Rampart Stands

Dolefully, A Rampart Stands

The women survive; they can take it, the ugliness. Dogs come back, lie atop them. Dogs come back with hatchets and flashlights. Do not judge what must be done to survive.

Read More

Cynthia Arrieu-King's Futureless Languages

Futureless Languages

We have to change the culture, the syntax and words that led us to the barbarity of our present culture. Cynthia Arrieu-King's Futureless Languages asks, how do we do that?

Read More

Invasive Species

It’s important to separate, politically and artistically, the difference between something that feels instant because the artist (or consumer) has just been made aware of it, from something that is…

Read More

Violet Energy Ingots

Here the domestic kitchen setting and lemony scent combines with the darker, mysterious “ash work” and “Mandible dream” to create a larger existential setting where questions of memory, which are…

Read More

Handholding: 5 Kinds: Sonic, Textual Engagements

In the preface to her 1998 Soft Skull Press book, Intermission, Tracie Morris writes that the book, her first print publication since her self-published, Chap-T-her Won, is one result of her spoken…

Read More

litanies said handedly: poetry, collage, & performance

His musical references are blues and jazz—not hip hop, rap or EDM—and his literary references are too traditional to appeal to an audience for which Tupac Shakur—not Saul Williams—is the pre-eminent…

Read More

Silk Poems

Silk Poems, in its small, delicate package, is monumental in scope, in its place as one part of Jen Bervin’s larger research project and also in its wide-ranging suggestiveness. The material book…

Read More

L’Heure Bleue, or the Judy Poems

Neat encapsulation of a book’s central concept or conceit serves every genre well save poetry. The very idea of asking of a book of poetry “What’s it about?” is suspect. Though we can always answer…

Read More

Archeophonics

The unnerving creaking of the wooden floor turns to a warm stripe of sun on the same floor.

Read More

The Most Foreign Country

First published in 1955 when Pizarnik was 19, she was later to renounce the book, which remained all but buried, even in Argentina, until it was reprinted in Poesia completa, published in 2000, 28…

Read More